Here’s the deal: You know Proposal 2 as Mop Up Michigan. It bans regulated utilities and companies with more than $250,000 a year in government contracts from donating to Michigan candidates and political parties. That ban covers their top executives and family members, too. It also forces dark money groups running ads to disclose who’s funding them. And now it’s facing two federal lawsuits.
The first one came from the Mackinac Center, hours after polls closed. It’s a conservative think tank in Midland, and they’re not challenging the utility ban, they’re going after the disclosure rules. They say they’re too vague.
The second one is the big one. DTE, Consumers, and their PACs. They want the donation ban itself thrown out. They say it singles out one industry, and that Michiganders shouldn’t lose their First Amendment rights because of where they work. One of the plaintiffs is the 86-year-old mother of DTE’s treasurer. Under Proposal 2, she can’t donate either.
And here’s the kicker: This case probably won’t come down to what voters wanted. It’ll come down to three words: Quid pro quo. Over the years, the US Supreme Court has whittled down the reasons a government can limit political money to basically one, stopping a direct trade of cash for official action, or the appearance of one. And in June, the court said it again. It ruled 6-3 to strike down limits on how much political parties can spend in coordination with their candidates. That’s the utility’s whole play here. Their lawsuit says Michigan has no scandal, no bribe, no example of a utility buying a vote. Just slogans and buzzwords.
Remember when I told you DTE gave money to 138 of 148 of our state lawmakers? Well, that looks bad. But in court, looking bad isn’t the same thing as proof, but it’s not that simple. Bans like this one have survived before. Connecticut banned state contractors, and even their spouses and kids, from donating to state candidates. A federal appeals court upheld it. Why? Well, because Connecticut’s governor went to federal prison over a contractor scandal. The court said that history created a real appearance of corruption.
Michigan doesn’t exactly have a scandal like that, but Ohio does. Right next door, FirstEnergy admitted to funneling about $60 million to the Ohio House speaker to pass a $1 billion bailout for its power plants. He got 20 years in prison. Whether a federal judge here will count a utility bribery scheme one state over is going to be a huge question.
So what? Well, Proposal 2 is set to take effect Dec. 3. The utilities want a judge to freeze it before then. So the first real decision is whether this law gets put on hold while the case plays out. Whoever loses will probably appeal to the Sixth Circuit. This could eventually land in front of the same Supreme Court that ruled in June. And watch who’s defending it. The lawsuit names Attorney General Dana Nessel, or her successor. Come January, that’s Eli Savit. He campaigned on refusing money from utilities, their lobbyists, and their executives. Now, his office will defend this law in court.
Get the full story in this edition of so what? Michigan.